Best Sulfate Free Dandruff Shampoos – Rated by BEAUTYGOORU Experts

Effectiveness on sulfate free dandruff statistics

Products Mentioned:326
Products with over 80% Positive Mention Rate:183
Total Mentions:21,849
Frequency in Reviews:12.1%
Frequency in Top Shampoos in attribute:39.1%
Importance Rank Among All Attributes:5
Average Positive Mention Rate in Top 20% Shampoos:80%

Dandruff is a common scalp condition that plagues many, characterized by flaking and sometimes an itchy scalp, which can be both uncomfortable and embarrassing. The quest for relief often leads individuals to a myriad of shampoos promising to combat this pesky issue. However, not all shampoos are created equal, and the effectiveness of a product can vary widely. One key factor in the fight against dandruff is the presence of sulfates in many shampoos. These harsh detergents can strip the scalp of its natural oils, potentially exacerbating dandruff and leading to further irritation.

Understanding the importance of a sulfate-free formula combined with potent dandruff-fighting ingredients is crucial for those seeking a healthy scalp. Sulfate-free shampoos can help maintain the natural balance of oils on the scalp, while active ingredients target the root causes of dandruff, such as Malassezia yeast. This dual approach can significantly improve scalp health and reduce flakiness.

However, navigating the vast market of hair care products can be daunting. According to our BeautyGooru team’s statistics, out of the myriad of products analyzed, 326 were specifically mentioned for their “Effectiveness on dandruff”, with a staggering 21,849 mentions highlighting this feature. This data underscores the challenge consumers face in finding a shampoo that not only claims to be effective but truly delivers results.

Real customer reviews serve as a beacon of guidance, offering insights into the actual performance of dandruff shampoos. These testimonials can highlight the successes and shortcomings of various products, helping potential buyers make informed decisions. Our BeautyGooru team has meticulously analyzed these reviews and ratings, considering both the number of products and the frequency of their effectiveness mentions. This comprehensive approach has culminated in a curated list of the 10 best sulfate-free dandruff shampoos for 2024, designed to steer you towards a flake-free, healthier scalp.

Our Top Picks:

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on dandruff” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff”

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women

Selsun Blue Moisturizing Anti-dandruff Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff”

Selsun Blue Moisturizing Anti-dandruff Shampoo

Selsun Blue Medicated Anti-dandruff Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best budget

Selsun Blue Medicated Anti-dandruff Shampoo

Head & Shoulders Supreme Sulfate Free Dandruff Shampoo photoBest popular
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on dandruff” and other attributes

Head & Shoulders Supreme Sulfate Free Dandruff Shampoo

Affirm: KeraCare Moisturizing Shampoo photoBest budget
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff”

Affirm: KeraCare Moisturizing Shampoo

Tea Tree Special Shampoo photoBest shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on dandruff” and other attributes

Tea Tree Special Shampoo

DHS Zinc Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular

DHS Zinc Shampoo

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo

Head & Shoulders Anti-Dandruff Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff”

Head & Shoulders Anti-Dandruff Shampoo

Biolage Scalp Sync Anti-Dandruff Shampoo photoBest popular

Biolage Scalp Sync Anti-Dandruff Shampoo

best sulfate free dandruff shampoo

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women photo

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on dandruff” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff” $12 at Amazon

BrandMaple Holistics
Amazon rating4.4
BeautyGooru rating4.6
Number of reviews4,988
Share of positive87%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”5
Number of mentions1,949
Share of positive mentions98%

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women by Maple Holistics stands out as a high-performing product among the top shampoos available on Amazon, with a price of $12.00. It is among the top-20% in terms of price and has garnered a significant number of reviews, placing it in the top-5% with an overall rating of 4.6, which is also in the top-5% of shampoos.

Pros

  • Effectiveness on dandruff (1949 mentions, 98% positive): This shampoo is highly effective against dandruff, ranking in the top-5% of shampoos for this attribute.
  • Natural Ingredients (674 mentions, 96% positive): The use of natural ingredients is well-received, placing it in the top-5% of shampoos for this quality.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (817 mentions, 98% positive): It excels in cleaning hair, with a top-5% ranking based on user feedback.
  • Impact on scalp health (3013 mentions, 87% positive): The shampoo has a positive impact on scalp health, making it a top-5% choice for consumers.
  • Scent (1720 mentions, 95% positive): Users are highly satisfied with the scent, earning it a place in the top-5% of shampoos.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (1618 mentions, 82% positive): It is effective in reducing hair dryness post-shampooing, ranking in the top-10%.
  • Effect on hair manageability (114 mentions, 97% positive): This shampoo improves hair manageability, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Shampoo chemical content (486 mentions, 74% positive): The chemical content is considered positive by users, ranking in the top-20%.
  • Improvement of hair health (549 mentions, 100% positive): It is highly effective in improving hair health, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Effect on shiny hair (248 mentions, 97% positive): The shampoo contributes to shinier hair, ranking it in the top-40%.

Average

  • Effectiveness on oily hair (177 mentions, 76% positive): It has an average effectiveness on oily hair, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Curly or Wavy hair users shampoo experiences (66 mentions, 90% positive): Users with curly or wavy hair have had positive experiences, ranking it in the top-20%.
  • Moisturizing effect (191 mentions, 80% positive): The moisturizing effect is average, placing it in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (87 mentions, 80% positive): It has an average effectiveness on frizz control, ranking in the top-30%.
  • Sulfate-free shampoo (110 mentions, 79% positive): The sulfate-free aspect is considered average, placing it in the top-40%.

Cons

  • Effect on hair tangling (36 mentions, 56% positive): There are some concerns about its effect on hair tangling, placing it in the top-60%.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (158 mentions, 55% positive): The effectiveness on hair loss is a concern, ranking it in the top-60%.
  • Effectiveness on thinning hair (111 mentions, 81% positive): It has a moderate effectiveness on thinning hair, placing it in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on fungal infections (57 mentions, 72% positive): The shampoo’s effectiveness on fungal infections is considered average, ranking in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on psoriasis (121 mentions, 78% positive): It has a moderate effectiveness on psoriasis, placing it in the top-40%.
Selsun Blue Moisturizing Anti-dandruff Shampoo photo

Selsun Blue Moisturizing Anti-dandruff Shampoo

Selsun Blue Moisturizing Anti-dandruff Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff” $7.5 at Amazon

BrandSelsun Blue
Amazon rating4.7
BeautyGooru rating4.3
Number of reviews684
Share of positive67%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.9
Number of mentions256
Share of positive mentions87%

Selsun Blue Moisturizing Anti-dandruff Shampoo is a highly regarded option among users for its scalp health benefits and dandruff control, with a strong overall rating of 4.3. It stands out in the market for its positive impact on scalp health and effectiveness against dandruff, though it has some drawbacks in terms of scent and hair manageability.

Pros

  • Impact on scalp health (166 mentions, 89% positive): Users frequently praise the shampoo for significantly improving scalp health, placing it in the top tier of shampoos for this benefit.
  • Effectiveness on dandruff (256 mentions, 87% positive): It is highly effective in combating dandruff, with a majority of users experiencing positive results, ranking it among the best for this issue.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (31 mentions, 90% positive): The shampoo is recognized for its ability to clean hair thoroughly, placing it well within the top third of shampoos.
  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (26 mentions, 100% positive): Every mention related to hair softness or silkiness is positive, indicating that users find it excellent for making hair feel soft and silky.

Average

  • Moisturizing effect (39 mentions, 76% positive): The shampoo has a decent moisturizing effect, with most users finding it satisfactory, though not exceptional.
  • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (16 mentions, 69% positive): It shows a good level of effectiveness in reducing flaky scalp, performing better than many other shampoos.
  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (6 mentions, 67% positive): Some users find it effective in removing residue or buildup, but it’s not a standout feature.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (127 mentions, 59% positive): While it helps to reduce hair dryness for some, it is not among the top performers in this category.
  • Effectiveness on fungal infections (16 mentions, 84% positive): Users report that it is quite effective against fungal infections, placing it in a good position compared to other shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (12 mentions, 83% positive): It is also effective in treating seborrheic dermatitis, according to a majority of users.
  • Natural Ingredients (9 mentions, 70% positive): Some users appreciate the inclusion of natural ingredients, though it’s not a leading feature.
  • Effect on shiny hair (13 mentions, 85% positive): While some users notice an improvement in hair shine, it is not among the best for this attribute.

Cons

  • Effectiveness on oily hair (10 mentions, 65% positive): The shampoo has moderate effectiveness on oily hair, with mixed feedback from users.
  • Scent (130 mentions, 43% positive): The scent is a notable downside, with less than half of the mentions being positive, indicating that many users are not fond of it.
  • Sulfate-free shampoo (2 mentions, 0% positive): It does not meet the expectations of users looking for a sulfate-free option.
  • Effect on hair manageability (3 mentions, 33% positive): There are concerns about its impact on hair manageability, with a majority of users finding it lacking in this area.
  • Effect on hair tangling (6 mentions, 33% positive): Users also report issues with hair tangling after use, suggesting it may not be the best choice for those with tangle-prone hair.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (12 mentions, 44% positive): The shampoo has mixed reviews regarding its effectiveness on hair loss, with less than half of the users finding it helpful.
  • Degreasing properties (2 mentions, 50% positive): Opinions are split on its degreasing properties, indicating it may not be the best for those with very oily hair.
  • Bleached hair maintenance (2 mentions, 0% positive): It is not recommended for maintaining bleached hair, as all mentions in this context are negative.
Selsun Blue Medicated Anti-dandruff Shampoo photo

Selsun Blue Medicated Anti-dandruff Shampoo

Selsun Blue Medicated Anti-dandruff Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best budget $7.5 at Amazon

BrandSelsun Blue
Amazon rating4.7
BeautyGooru rating4.5
Number of reviews1,007
Share of positive70%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.5
Number of mentions379
Share of positive mentions84%

Selsun Blue Medicated Anti-dandruff Shampoo is a highly rated anti-dandruff shampoo that stands out for its effectiveness on dandruff and scalp health, with a majority of users experiencing positive results. It is priced among the top 5% of shampoos and has a strong reputation for treating fungal infections and seborrheic dermatitis. However, it has some drawbacks in terms of hair manageability and scent, according to user feedback.

Pros

  • Effectiveness on dandruff (379 mentions, 84% positive): This shampoo is highly praised for its ability to combat dandruff, placing it in the top 5% of shampoos for this benefit.
  • Impact on scalp health (258 mentions, 80% positive): Users report significant improvements in scalp health, ranking it in the top 10% of shampoos for this attribute.
  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (16 mentions, 100% positive): Although mentioned less frequently, every review that touched on this aspect was positive, placing it in the top 30% of shampoos for making hair feel soft or silky.
  • Effectiveness on fungal infections (63 mentions, 81% positive): It is considered highly effective against fungal infections, with a ranking in the top 10% of shampoos for this issue.

Average

  • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (35 mentions, 74% positive): It shows a good level of effectiveness in treating seborrheic dermatitis, placing it in the top 20% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on damaged hair (11 mentions, 77% positive): Some users found it beneficial for damaged hair, ranking it in the top 30% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness in hair strengthening (5 mentions, 90% positive): While not a common mention, those who did found it effective in strengthening hair, placing it in the top 50% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (16 mentions, 66% positive): It has a moderate success rate for removing residue or buildup, ranking in the top 50% of shampoos.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (119 mentions, 46% positive): Opinions are mixed on its ability to reduce hair dryness, placing it in the top 60% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (32 mentions, 81% positive): Most users agree on its cleaning efficacy, ranking it in the top 60% of shampoos.
  • Sulfate-free shampoo (5 mentions, 60% positive): It is considered average in terms of being sulfate-free, placing it in the top 50% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (18 mentions, 60% positive): It is moderately effective on flaky scalps, ranking in the top 30% of shampoos.

Cons

  • Effect on hair tangling (8 mentions, 63% positive): Some users experienced issues with hair tangling, placing it in the top 50% of shampoos.
  • Effect on hair manageability (4 mentions, 38% positive): It ranks in the bottom 20% of shampoos for hair manageability, indicating a notable concern.
  • Improvement of hair health (28 mentions, 69% positive): Despite some positive feedback, it falls in the bottom 20% of shampoos for improving overall hair health.
  • Effect on shiny hair (7 mentions, 71% positive): It ranks in the bottom 10% of shampoos for enhancing hair shine, suggesting that it may not be the best option for those seeking luster.
  • Scent (151 mentions, 46% positive): The scent is a significant downside, with it ranking in the bottom 20% of shampoos.
  • Natural Ingredients (11 mentions, 55% positive): It is considered below average in terms of natural ingredient content, placing it in the bottom 30% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on oily hair (10 mentions, 55% positive): It ranks in the bottom 30% for treating oily hair, indicating limited effectiveness for this hair type.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (18 mentions, 42% positive): While not its primary focus, it ranks in the top 60% of shampoos for addressing hair loss.
Head & Shoulders Supreme Sulfate Free Dandruff Shampoo photo

Head & Shoulders Supreme Sulfate Free Dandruff Shampoo

Head & Shoulders Supreme Sulfate Free Dandruff Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best popular
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on dandruff” and other attributes $23.8 at Amazon

BrandHead & Shoulders
Amazon rating4.6
BeautyGooru rating4.1
Number of reviews426
Share of positive78%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.5
Number of mentions182
Share of positive mentions76%

Head & Shoulders Supreme Sulfate Free Dandruff Shampoo stands out among popular shampoos on Amazon for its high ratings in softness, scent, and dandruff control, placing it in the top 5% for these attributes. It also scores well in other key areas, making it a favored choice for consumers seeking a variety of hair benefits.

Pros

  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (113 mentions, 99% positive): Users frequently praise the shampoo for significantly enhancing the softness and silkiness of their hair, ranking it among the best.
  • Scent (213 mentions, 89% positive): The pleasant fragrance of this shampoo is highly appreciated by users, contributing to its top-tier status in this category.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (59 mentions, 91% positive): It is recognized for its ability to clean hair thoroughly, placing it well within the top 20% of shampoos.
  • Effect on shiny hair (50 mentions, 86% positive): This shampoo is commended for imparting a noticeable shine to hair, securing a spot in the top 10%.
  • Effect on hair manageability (21 mentions, 88% positive): Users find that it improves hair manageability, ranking it in the top 10% for this benefit.
  • Improvement of hair health (68 mentions, 88% positive): Many users report an overall improvement in hair health, placing the shampoo in the top 20% for this attribute.
  • Effectiveness on dandruff (182 mentions, 76% positive): It is highly effective against dandruff, as evidenced by its ranking in the top 5% for this concern.
  • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (26 mentions, 83% positive): The shampoo is also recognized for its ability to control frizz, placing it in the top 30%.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (144 mentions, 61% positive): It helps to reduce hair dryness post-shampooing, ranking in the top 30% for this attribute.

Average

  • Moisturizing effect (32 mentions, 81% positive): The shampoo has a decent moisturizing effect, placing it in the top 40%.
  • Impact on scalp health (175 mentions, 64% positive): It positively impacts scalp health, ranking in the top 20%.
  • Natural Ingredients (15 mentions, 81% positive): Users appreciate the inclusion of natural ingredients, positioning it in the top 40%.
  • Effectiveness on Damaged hair (12 mentions, 83% positive): The shampoo is quite effective on damaged hair, placing it in the top 30%.
  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (33 mentions, 60% positive): It performs adequately in removing residue or buildup, ranking in the top 40%.
  • Shampoo chemical content (31 mentions, 66% positive): The chemical content of the shampoo is generally well-received, placing it in the top 40%.

Cons

  • Curly or Wavy hair users shampoo experiences (14 mentions, 69% positive): The experiences of users with curly or wavy hair are less favorable, placing this shampoo in the bottom 30% for this group.
  • Effect on hair tangling (10 mentions, 70% positive): While it has a positive effect on hair tangling, it still ranks in the top 40%, indicating room for improvement.
  • Provision of fuller and voluminous hair (2 mentions, 100% positive): There are few mentions of the shampoo providing fuller, more voluminous hair, placing it in the bottom 30% due to limited feedback.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (11 mentions, 64% positive): Its effectiveness on hair loss is average, ranking it in the top 50%.
  • Effectiveness on oily hair (7 mentions, 43% positive): The shampoo is less effective for users with oily hair, placing it in the bottom 30% for this concern.
Affirm: KeraCare Moisturizing Shampoo photo

Affirm: KeraCare Moisturizing Shampoo

Affirm: KeraCare Moisturizing Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best budget
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff” $9.3 at Amazon

BrandAffirm
Amazon rating4.7
BeautyGooru rating3.7
Number of reviews93
Share of positive72%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.7
Number of mentions37
Share of positive mentions85%

Affirm: KeraCare Moisturizing Shampoo stands out for its effectiveness against dandruff and flaky scalp, as well as its positive impact on scalp health. However, it shows room for improvement in hair cleaning, reducing dryness, and enhancing manageability.

Pros

    • Effectiveness on dandruff (37 mentions, 85% positive): This shampoo is highly praised for its ability to combat dandruff, ranking it in the top 5% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (5 mentions, 80% positive): Users find it effective for flaky scalp issues, placing it in the top 10% of shampoos.
    • Impact on scalp health (44 mentions, 81% positive): It is recognized for its beneficial effects on overall scalp health, ranking in the top 20% of shampoos.

Average

    • Scent (8 mentions, 88% positive): The scent of this shampoo is generally well-received, placing it in the top 40% of shampoos.
    • Moisturizing effect (2 mentions, 100% positive): While it receives positive feedback for its moisturizing effect, it is less frequently mentioned, ranking in the bottom 30% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (7 mentions, 14% positive): Its performance in removing residue or buildup is considered average, placing it in the bottom 30% of shampoos.
    • Improvement of hair health (2 mentions, 100% positive): Although it has positive mentions for improving hair health, the low number of mentions puts it in the bottom 30% of shampoos.

Cons

    • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (8 mentions, 63% positive): This shampoo could be more effective in cleaning hair, as it ranks in the bottom 20% of shampoos.
    • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (19 mentions, 52% positive): It has a lower ranking for reducing hair dryness post-shampooing, placing it in the bottom 20% of shampoos.
    • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (2 mentions, 100% positive): Despite positive feedback, the low frequency of mentions ranks it in the bottom 10% for improving hair softness or silkiness.
    • Shampoo chemical content (7 mentions, 43% positive): Concerns about its chemical content place it in the bottom 30% of shampoos.
    • Effect on hair manageability (3 mentions, 33% positive): It scores low on enhancing hair manageability, ranking in the bottom 10% of shampoos.
    • Natural Ingredients (3 mentions, 33% positive): The use of natural ingredients is not a strong point, placing it in the bottom 10% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on thinning hair (3 mentions, 100% positive): It receives positive feedback for its effect on thinning hair, ranking it in the top 40% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Hair Growth (2 mentions, 100% positive): It is also positively reviewed for promoting hair growth, placing it in the top 40% of shampoos.
Tea Tree Special Shampoo photo

Tea Tree Special Shampoo

Tea Tree Special Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on dandruff” and other attributes


$18 at Amazon

BrandTea Tree
Amazon rating4.7
BeautyGooru rating4.5
Number of reviews4,147
Share of positive81%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”3.8
Number of mentions407
Share of positive mentions85%

Tea Tree Special Shampoo stands out as a high-performing product among popular shampoos on Amazon, with a strong reputation for improving scalp health and effectively cleaning hair. Its scent and impact on oily hair are particularly praised, while it also shows commendable results in hair health improvement and residue removal.

Pros

  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (617 mentions, 94% positive): This shampoo ranks in the top 10% for its ability to clean hair thoroughly, leaving users satisfied with its cleansing properties.
  • Impact on scalp health (1025 mentions, 89% positive): With a top 5% ranking, the shampoo is highly regarded for its beneficial effects on scalp health, making it a favorite for those with scalp concerns.
  • Scent (1184 mentions, 86% positive): The pleasant fragrance of this shampoo places it in the top 10%, with a majority of users enjoying its aroma.
  • Effectiveness on oily hair (149 mentions, 85% positive): It excels in the top 5% for managing oily hair, indicating its suitability for those struggling with excess oil.
  • Improvement of hair health (247 mentions, 94% positive): Users have noted a significant improvement in hair health, positioning this shampoo in the top 30% for this attribute.
  • Effect on shiny hair (95 mentions, 88% positive): This shampoo contributes to shinier hair, ranking it in the top 50% of shampoos for enhancing hair’s natural shine.
  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (116 mentions, 80% positive): It is recognized in the top 30% for its ability to remove residue or buildup, ensuring cleaner hair and scalp.

Average

  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (194 mentions, 93% positive): The shampoo has a positive effect on hair softness or silkiness, placing it in the top 50% for this quality.
  • Effectiveness on dandruff (407 mentions, 85% positive): It ranks in the top 10% for dandruff control, showing its efficacy in addressing this common scalp issue.
  • Effect on hair manageability (30 mentions, 77% positive): The shampoo aids in hair manageability, earning it a spot in the top 30%.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (457 mentions, 68% positive): It is in the top 40% for reducing hair dryness post-shampooing, indicating a moisturizing effect.
  • Effectiveness in hair strengthening (14 mentions, 96% positive): Although not as frequently mentioned, it ranks in the top 50% for strengthening hair.
  • Squeaky clean hair feeling after shampoo use (25 mentions, 96% positive): Users report a squeaky clean feeling after use, placing the shampoo in the top 30% for this sensation.
  • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (33 mentions, 70% positive): It shows average performance in frizz control, ranking in the top 50%.

Cons

  • Effectiveness in hair color preservation (22 mentions, 82% positive): This shampoo falls in the bottom 40% when it comes to preserving hair color, suggesting it may not be the best choice for color-treated hair.
  • Natural Ingredients (55 mentions, 49% positive): Concerns about the naturalness of ingredients place this product in the bottom 20%, indicating a desire for more organic components.
  • Effect on hair tangling (25 mentions, 56% positive): It ranks in the bottom 40% for reducing hair tangling, which may be an area for improvement.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (71 mentions, 44% positive): While not its strongest suit, it still ranks in the top 60% for addressing hair loss concerns.
  • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (33 mentions, 78% positive): The shampoo is in the top 40% for combating a flaky scalp, showing a decent level of effectiveness.
  • Effectiveness on thinning hair (46 mentions, 51% positive): It is in the top 40% for helping with thinning hair, although there is room for improvement in this area.
DHS Zinc Shampoo photo

DHS Zinc Shampoo

DHS Zinc Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular


$15 at Amazon

BrandDHS
Amazon rating4.5
BeautyGooru rating4.4
Number of reviews1,082
Share of positive75%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.6
Number of mentions282
Share of positive mentions85%

DHS Zinc Shampoo is a highly regarded option among users, particularly for its positive impact on scalp health, effectiveness on dandruff, and its ability to improve damaged hair and seborrheic dermatitis. With an overall rating of 4.4, it stands among the top shampoos available on Amazon.

Pros

  • Impact on scalp health (446 mentions, 87% positive): This shampoo is celebrated for its significant positive impact on scalp health, placing it in the top echelon of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on damaged hair (19 mentions, 95% positive): It is highly effective in treating damaged hair, ranking it well above many competitors.
  • Effectiveness on dandruff (282 mentions, 85% positive): Users have found it to be extremely effective against dandruff, making it one of the best options for this issue.
  • Effect on hair manageability (16 mentions, 88% positive): The shampoo has a notable positive effect on hair manageability, positioning it among the top choices.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (67 mentions, 90% positive): It is recognized for its ability to clean hair thoroughly, which is appreciated by users.
  • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (116 mentions, 77% positive): Its effectiveness in treating seborrheic dermatitis is highly regarded, placing it among the top shampoos for this condition.
  • Improvement of hair health (40 mentions, 94% positive): The shampoo contributes to the overall improvement of hair health, according to user feedback.
  • Effect on shiny hair (23 mentions, 89% positive): Users have reported that it enhances the shininess of their hair, making it a favorable option for those seeking luster.

Average

  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (34 mentions, 94% positive): The shampoo has a generally positive effect on hair softness or silkiness, with most users satisfied with the results.
  • Effectiveness in hair strengthening (6 mentions, 100% positive): Although not as frequently mentioned, it is considered effective in strengthening hair.
  • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (27 mentions, 63% positive): It shows a moderate level of effectiveness in addressing flaky scalp concerns.
  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (23 mentions, 67% positive): The shampoo is fairly effective in removing residue or buildup from the hair.
  • Moisturizing effect (4 mentions, 75% positive): Some users have found it to have a moisturizing effect, although this is not its most highlighted feature.
  • Shampoo chemical content (46 mentions, 37% positive): The chemical content of the shampoo receives mixed reviews, with a notable number of users expressing concerns.

Cons

  • Effectiveness on oily hair (20 mentions, 68% positive): While it does help some users with oily hair, it is not the strongest performer in this category.
  • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (7 mentions, 43% positive): The shampoo is less effective in controlling frizz, as indicated by less than half of the mentions being positive.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (33 mentions, 64% positive): Its effectiveness on hair loss is average, with a positive response from just over half of the users who mentioned this aspect.
  • Natural Ingredients (19 mentions, 39% positive): Users are not particularly impressed with the natural ingredient content of the shampoo, placing it among the lower-rated shampoos in this regard.
  • Effectiveness in hair color preservation (6 mentions, 67% positive): It is not highly regarded for preserving hair color, with a minority of users finding it effective.
  • Effect on hair tangling (4 mentions, 50% positive): The shampoo has a middling performance when it comes to reducing hair tangling.
Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo photo

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular


$16.9 at Amazon

BrandNeutrogena
Amazon rating4.6
BeautyGooru rating4.4
Number of reviews2,526
Share of positive62%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.5
Number of mentions772
Share of positive mentions81%

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo stands out for its effectiveness in treating scalp conditions such as psoriasis, dandruff, and flaky scalp, with high positive feedback from users. However, it falls short in areas like scent and hair strengthening, with a notable number of negative reviews.

Pros

    • Effectiveness on psoriasis (195 mentions, 87% positive): This shampoo is highly praised for its ability to alleviate psoriasis symptoms, ranking it among the top shampoos for this condition.
    • Effectiveness on dandruff (772 mentions, 81% positive): A significant number of users have found it effective in reducing dandruff, placing it in the top tier for dandruff treatment.
    • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (106 mentions, 90% positive): It is recognized for its strong cleaning capabilities, making it a reliable choice for hair hygiene.
    • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (86 mentions, 79% positive): Users report that it effectively combats flaky scalp issues, securing its position as a top choice for this concern.

Average

    • Impact on scalp health (898 mentions, 72% positive): The shampoo has a generally positive impact on overall scalp health, with a majority of users noting improvements.
    • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (74 mentions, 82% positive): It shows good results for those dealing with seborrheic dermatitis, with a high percentage of positive experiences.
    • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (46 mentions, 89% positive): Some users find that it contributes to softer or silkier hair, although this is not its primary benefit.
    • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (45 mentions, 63% positive): It is moderately effective at removing residue or buildup from the hair.
    • Effectiveness on damaged hair (48 mentions, 71% positive): The shampoo has a fair success rate in treating damaged hair according to user feedback.
    • Moisturizing effect (8 mentions, 75% positive): A small number of users mention a moisturizing effect, but it is not a standout feature.
    • Effect on hair manageability (11 mentions, 64% positive): It has an average impact on making hair more manageable.
    • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (308 mentions, 51% positive): Opinions are split on its ability to reduce hair dryness, with about half of the users noticing an improvement.

Cons

    • Effectiveness on oily hair (40 mentions, 59% positive): The shampoo has mixed results when it comes to treating oily hair, with a slight majority finding it effective.
    • Scent (925 mentions, 38% positive): The scent is a significant downside, with a large number of users disliking it.
    • Effectiveness in hair strengthening (13 mentions, 85% positive): Despite a high percentage of positive mentions, the low number of mentions suggests it is not a notable benefit.
    • Effectiveness on frizz control (14 mentions, 52% positive): It has a below-average performance in controlling frizz according to user reviews.
    • Natural ingredients (33 mentions, 55% positive): There is some concern about the naturalness of the ingredients, with a moderate level of satisfaction.
    • Effectiveness in hair color preservation (14 mentions, 62% positive): It does not excel in preserving hair color, with a relatively low number of positive mentions.
    • Effectiveness on hair loss (49 mentions, 43% positive): The shampoo is not highly regarded for treating hair loss, with more users reporting dissatisfaction.
    • Squeaky clean hair feeling after shampoo use (3 mentions, 67% positive): There are very few mentions of the shampoo leaving a squeaky clean feeling, indicating it is not a significant feature.
Head & Shoulders Anti-Dandruff Shampoo photo

Head & Shoulders Anti-Dandruff Shampoo

Head & Shoulders Anti-Dandruff Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on dandruff”
Best popular
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on dandruff”


$39 at Amazon

BrandHead & Shoulders
Amazon rating4.3
BeautyGooru rating4.1
Number of reviews493
Share of positive81%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.8
Number of mentions50
Share of positive mentions85%

Head & Shoulders Anti-Dandruff Shampoo stands out as a highly effective solution for dandruff control and scalp health, with a notable performance in frizz control and hair dryness reduction. While it offers a range of benefits, it falls short in areas such as scent and chemical content according to user reviews.

Pros

    • Effectiveness on dandruff (50 mentions, 85% positive): This shampoo is among the top 5% of shampoos for its high efficacy in combating dandruff, as reported by a significant number of users.
    • Impact on scalp health (25 mentions, 86% positive): Users have positively rated its impact on scalp health, placing it in the top 10% of shampoos for this attribute.
    • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (4 mentions, 100% positive): It is recognized in the top 20% of shampoos for its ability to control frizz effectively.
    • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (10 mentions, 80% positive): The shampoo is in the top 30% for reducing hair dryness post-wash, according to user feedback.
    • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (8 mentions, 88% positive): It ranks in the top 50% of shampoos for its cleaning efficacy, as noted by users.

Average

    • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (8 mentions, 100% positive): The shampoo has an average ranking in the bottom 40% for improving hair softness or silkiness, despite positive feedback.
    • Effect on shiny hair (7 mentions, 86% positive): It also falls in the bottom 40% for enhancing hair shine, based on user reviews.
    • Effectiveness on oily hair (3 mentions, 100% positive): For oily hair management, it is placed in the top 40%, showing a mixed performance.
    • Improvement of hair health (3 mentions, 100% positive): The shampoo’s effect on overall hair health is rated in the bottom 40%, indicating room for improvement.
    • Effectiveness on hair loss (3 mentions, 89% positive): It is in the top 40% for addressing hair loss concerns, as per user experiences.
    • Effectiveness on Damaged hair (6 mentions, 17% positive): Its performance on damaged hair is less impressive, placing it in the bottom 30%.

Cons

    • Scent (13 mentions, 62% positive): The fragrance of the shampoo is considered a downside, with it being in the bottom 20% for scent satisfaction.
    • Shampoo chemical content (3 mentions, 33% positive): Concerns about its chemical ingredients place it in the bottom 10% of shampoos, indicating a significant area for improvement.
Biolage Scalp Sync Anti-Dandruff Shampoo photo

Biolage Scalp Sync Anti-Dandruff Shampoo

Biolage Scalp Sync Anti-Dandruff Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best popular


$32 at Amazon

BrandBIOLAGE
Amazon rating4.7
BeautyGooru rating4.3
Number of reviews656
Share of positive70%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on dandruff”4.5
Number of mentions321
Share of positive mentions84%

Biolage Scalp Sync Anti-Dandruff Shampoo is a highly effective solution for dandruff and damaged hair, with strong degreasing properties and a notable impact on hair softness. It performs well in scalp health and has a pleasant scent, but has mixed results in other areas such as hair tangling and effectiveness on oily hair.

Pros

  • Effectiveness on Damaged Hair (8 mentions, 100% positive): This shampoo is among the top performers for repairing and nurturing damaged hair, as indicated by its unanimous positive feedback.
  • Effectiveness on Dandruff (321 mentions, 84% positive): With a high volume of mentions and a strong positive response, it ranks in the top tier for dandruff treatment.
  • Degreasing Properties (8 mentions, 100% positive): Users report excellent results in removing excess oil, placing it among the best for degreasing.
  • Effect on Hair Softness or Silkiness (45 mentions, 98% positive): The shampoo is highly praised for its ability to make hair feel soft and silky, ranking well within its category.

Average

  • Impact on Scalp Health (242 mentions, 67% positive): It has a positive impact on scalp health, with a majority of users noting improvements.
  • Scent (156 mentions, 79% positive): The fragrance of the shampoo is generally well-received, placing it in the upper range for scent.
  • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (8 mentions, 75% positive): It shows a decent performance in managing frizz, according to a majority of users.
  • Effectiveness on Flaky Scalp (20 mentions, 70% positive): This shampoo is fairly effective in reducing flakiness on the scalp.
  • Effectiveness in Hair Strengthening (4 mentions, 100% positive): Although not widely mentioned, it receives full positive feedback for strengthening hair.
  • Hair Dryness Reduction after Shampooing (138 mentions, 54% positive): It has a moderate success rate in reducing hair dryness post-use.
  • Effectiveness in Hair Color Preservation (19 mentions, 89% positive): The shampoo is quite effective in maintaining hair color, as reported by a large portion of users.
  • Effectiveness in Cleaning Hair (52 mentions, 77% positive): While still mostly positive, it ranks lower compared to other shampoos in terms of cleaning efficacy.

Cons

  • Curly or Wavy Hair Users Shampoo Experiences (7 mentions, 71% positive): Users with curly or wavy hair have given mixed feedback, indicating room for improvement.
  • Effect on Hair Tangling (7 mentions, 67% positive): Some users find it less effective in preventing hair tangling.
  • Effectiveness on Fungal Infections (8 mentions, 63% positive): It shows some potential in addressing fungal infections, but not as high as other areas.
  • Natural Ingredients (9 mentions, 47% positive): There is some concern about the natural ingredient content, with less than half of the mentions being positive.
  • Effectiveness on Oily Hair (18 mentions, 53% positive): The shampoo has a lower success rate for users with oily hair.
  • Effectiveness on Thinning Hair (7 mentions, 57% positive): It receives moderate feedback for its impact on thinning hair.
  • Effectiveness on Psoriasis (6 mentions, 67% positive): While some users find it helpful for psoriasis, it’s not universally acclaimed.
  • Effectiveness on Seborrheic Dermatitis (5 mentions, 60% positive): It has a moderate level of effectiveness for treating seborrheic dermatitis.

How We Rank

We strongly believe that reviews of actual customers who used shampoo is the best source of information on actual performance of a shampoo and in particular of detailed performance aspects like effectiveness for different hair types, various health, visual and tactile effects and also side effects. To make our analysis and scoring we apply the following methodology:

  • We use AI to analyze reviews in shampoo category and identify major topics on which customers focus their attention when reviewing a shampoo such as performance for different types of hair, scent, effectiveness against scalp and hair problems such as dryness, flakiness or oiliness and such other effects like moisturizing, shine, effect on hair tangling etc.
  • After identification of major topics within shampoo category which we name product attributes we use proprietary AI algorithms to find all mentions on every traced attribute for every shampoo which we take into research.
  • For every shampoo and attribute we calculate many metrics like total number of mentions on attribute, its share in total reviews, share of positive and negative sentiments etc. We then compare these metrics for different shampoos and elaborate comparative score of every shampoo against its peers and make it separately for every attribute.

Why Trust BeautyGooru?

In a digital space filled with conflicting information and sponsored content, Deborah Jones offers an oasis of trust. Her dedication to truth and efficiency, her deep understanding of beauty and wellness products, and her innovative use of technology ensure that when Deborah recommends the best shampoo for oily hair, she’s providing advice you can rely on. With Deborah and BeautyGooru, you’re not just getting suggestions; you’re getting the right solution.

8 Comments
  1. I’ve sensitive skin and many dandruff shampoos irritate my scalp. Would sulfate-free options be gentler while still addressing the flakes?

    • Sulfate-free dandruff shampoos are indeed designed to be gentler on the scalp while still effectively addressing flakiness and other symptoms associated with dandruff. Sulfates, such as sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) and sodium laureth sulfate (SLES), are detergents commonly used in shampoos for their lathering properties. However, they can also strip natural oils from the scalp and hair, leading to irritation, dryness, and exacerbating scalp sensitivity.

      For individuals with sensitive skin, sulfate-free dandruff shampoos can offer a milder cleansing option. These shampoos use alternative surfactants that are less harsh, reducing the risk of scalp irritation while still removing dandruff-causing sebum and buildup. Additionally, many sulfate-free options are formulated with soothing and moisturizing ingredients like tea tree oil, zinc pyrithione, salicylic acid, and natural oils and extracts. These ingredients help to calm the scalp, reduce inflammation, and tackle the root causes of dandruff, such as Malassezia yeast.

      It’s important to note that while sulfate-free dandruff shampoos are gentler and can be effective, the key to choosing the right product lies in identifying the specific cause of your dandruff and scalp issues. For instance:

      – Zinc pyrithione is effective against fungus-related dandruff.
      – Salicylic acid helps remove scale buildup.
      – Tea tree oil has antifungal and antibacterial properties that can soothe the scalp.
      – Ketoconazole is a potent antifungal, often recommended for severe dandruff or seborrheic dermatitis, and can be found in some sulfate-free formulations.

      Using a sulfate-free dandruff shampoo can be a part of a gentle yet effective scalp care regimen. However, if your scalp condition does not improve or worsens, it’s advisable to consult with a dermatologist to receive a tailored treatment plan. Dermatologists can offer insight into the specific condition affecting your scalp and recommend specialized treatments or products that can provide relief without causing further irritation.

  2. I color my hair regularly. Do sulfate-free dandruff shampoos help in retaining the hair color for a longer time?

    • Sulfate-free dandruff shampoos can indeed help in retaining hair color for a longer period. Sulfates, commonly found in many shampoos, are effective cleansers but can be harsh on dyed hair, leading to faster fading of color. By opting for sulfate-free options, you reduce the risk of stripping away the hair dye, thus preserving the vibrancy and longevity of your hair color.

      These shampoos are formulated with gentler surfactants that cleanse the scalp and hair without removing essential oils or hair dye molecules. This not only helps in maintaining the color but also keeps the hair healthier and more moisturized. Additionally, many sulfate-free dandruff shampoos contain ingredients like antioxidants and UV protectants that further protect the hair color from fading due to environmental factors.

      For colored hair, it’s also beneficial to look for shampoos specifically designed for color-treated hair, which may also address dandruff without compromising color retention. Remember, while sulfate-free shampoos can aid in color preservation, other factors such as the quality of the dye, exposure to sun, and the use of heat styling tools also play significant roles in how long your hair color lasts.

  3. I’ve always believed sulfates were necessary to effectively combat dandruff. How do sulfate-free shampoos manage to stay effective?

    • Sulfate-free dandruff shampoos can indeed be just as effective as their sulfate-containing counterparts, but they employ a different mechanism to combat dandruff. The key to their effectiveness lies in the use of alternative surfactants and active ingredients that are gentler on the scalp yet effective in managing dandruff symptoms.

      1. Gentler Surfactants: Sulfates are detergents that help to create lather and remove oil, dirt, and product buildup from the scalp and hair. However, they can be harsh, stripping natural oils and irritating the scalp, which can exacerbate dandruff for some individuals. Sulfate-free shampoos use milder surfactants like cocamidopropyl betaine, decyl glucoside, or lauryl glucoside, which cleanse the scalp without stripping it excessively, maintaining the natural balance of oils and helping to prevent irritation and dryness.

      2. Active Ingredients: Sulfate-free dandruff shampoos often contain active ingredients targeted at dandruff, such as zinc pyrithione, salicylic acid, tea tree oil, or ketoconazole. These ingredients address the root causes of dandruff, such as fungal growth and excessive skin cell turnover, without the need for harsh cleansing agents.

      3. Moisturizing and Soothing Components: These shampoos also frequently incorporate moisturizing and soothing ingredients like aloe vera, argan oil, or shea butter to help soothe the scalp and reduce flakiness and irritation. Maintaining a well-hydrated scalp can help minimize dandruff symptoms.

      4. pH Balance: A balanced scalp pH is crucial in managing dandruff. Sulfate-free shampoos are often formulated to maintain or restore the natural pH balance of the scalp, reducing the risk of irritation and dandruff.

      By focusing on maintaining the scalp’s health and directly targeting the causes of dandruff with specific active ingredients, sulfate-free shampoos can effectively manage dandruff while also being gentler on the scalp and hair. This makes them a suitable option for individuals with sensitive skin, eczema, or those who wish to avoid harsh chemicals in their hair care routine.

  4. Do these sulfate-free shampoos have a pleasant fragrance? I’ve tried a few in the past, and they didn’t smell great.

    • Understanding your concern, Sienna, it’s important to note that the formulation of sulfate-free shampoos, especially those targeting dandruff, has significantly advanced in recent years. Manufacturers have increasingly focused on enhancing the sensory experience of using these products, which includes improving their fragrance.

      Sulfate-free shampoos are formulated without harsh surfactants, which means they rely on milder ingredients for cleansing. This shift has allowed for the incorporation of natural and essential oils, which not only provide effective moisture and treatment for the scalp but also impart a more pleasant and often therapeutic aroma to the shampoo. Ingredients like tea tree oil, peppermint, lavender, and eucalyptus are commonly used for their natural antifungal and antibacterial properties, which are beneficial in treating dandruff, and these ingredients naturally smell refreshing or soothing.

      Furthermore, many brands are now keenly aware that the olfactory experience can significantly influence a product’s appeal. As a result, they are meticulously crafting their formulas to ensure that the absence of sulfates doesn’t lead to a compromise in how enjoyable the product is to use, including its smell. This involves carefully balancing natural fragrances to offer a pleasant scent profile that can rival or even surpass those found in traditional shampoos.

      When selecting a sulfate-free dandruff shampoo, it might be helpful to look for products that highlight their natural fragrance ingredients or those that have reviews mentioning their scent positively. Keep in mind that fragrance is subjective, and what might be appealing to one person could be less so to another. Therefore, if possible, testing a small sample or purchasing travel-sized versions can be a good strategy to find a product that meets both your scalp care needs and your fragrance preferences without committing to a full-sized bottle.

    Leave a reply

    BEAUTYGOORU
    Logo
    Compare items
    • Total (0)
    Compare
    0