Best Shampoos for Itchy Scalp – Rated by BEAUTYGOORU Experts

Effectiveness on itchy scalp statistics

Products Mentioned:74
Products with over 80% Positive Mention Rate:79
Total Mentions:2,046
Frequency in Reviews:2.3%
Frequency in Top Shampoos in attribute:5.2%
Importance Rank Among All Attributes:48
Average Positive Mention Rate in Top 20% Shampoos:76%

An itchy scalp can be a persistent and uncomfortable problem, often leading to frustration and embarrassment for those who suffer from it. The causes of scalp itchiness are varied, ranging from dandruff and seborrheic dermatitis to more simple factors like dry skin or sensitivity to hair care products. The discomfort can be exacerbated by environmental factors such as weather changes or stress, making it a widespread issue that many seek to resolve.

Shampoos, specifically formulated to address itchy scalp, can offer relief by targeting the underlying issues. They often contain ingredients designed to soothe irritation, reduce flakiness, and restore the natural balance of the scalp’s microbiome. Effectiveness on flaky scalp and impact on scalp health are critical features to consider when selecting a shampoo, as they directly influence the product’s ability to alleviate symptoms and promote long-term scalp wellness.

Finding the right shampoo for an itchy scalp can be daunting. According to our BeautyGooru team’s statistics, out of the myriad products available, only 74 have been noted for their effectiveness on flaky scalp, with a total of 2046 mentions. This highlights the challenge consumers face in identifying shampoos that are truly efficacious for their specific needs.

Customer reviews play a pivotal role in navigating this crowded market. Real-world experiences and testimonials can shed light on the actual performance of shampoos, guiding potential buyers towards products that have proven successful for others with similar issues.

Our BeautyGooru team has taken the guesswork out of this process. By analyzing the above number of shampoos and mentions, we have curated a list of the 10 best shampoos for itchy scalp in 2024. Our rating is grounded in comprehensive research and customer feedback, ensuring that you have access to the most effective solutions for maintaining a healthy, itch-free scalp.

Our Top Picks:

TheraNeem Scalp Therapy Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”

TheraNeem Scalp Therapy Shampoo

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Impact on scalp health”

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women

JVN Pre-Wash Scalp Oil & Hair Treatment Oil photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”

JVN Pre-Wash Scalp Oil & Hair Treatment Oil

Neutrogena T/Sal Therapeutic Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Impact on scalp health”

Neutrogena T/Sal Therapeutic Shampoo

Sage and Rosemary Sulfate Free Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”

Sage and Rosemary Sulfate Free Shampoo

Davines Naturaltech PURIFYING Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”

Davines Naturaltech PURIFYING Shampoo

Trader Joe's Tea Tree Tingle Shampoo photoBest shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Impact on scalp health”

Trader Joe’s Tea Tree Tingle Shampoo

Ethique Heali Kiwi Calming Solid Shampoo Bar photoBest shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”

Ethique Heali Kiwi Calming Solid Shampoo Bar

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo photoBest brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo

Puriya Sulfate Free Tea Tree Shampoo photoBest shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”

Puriya Sulfate Free Tea Tree Shampoo

best shampoo for itchy scalp

TheraNeem Scalp Therapy Shampoo photo

TheraNeem Scalp Therapy Shampoo

TheraNeem Scalp Therapy Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” $15 at Amazon

BrandThera Neem
Amazon rating4.4
BeautyGooru rating3.8
Number of reviews251
Share of positive69%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”4.8
Number of mentions8
Share of positive mentions88%

TheraNeem Scalp Therapy Shampoo stands out for its effectiveness on flaky and oily scalps, as well as its ability to enhance hair shine, health, and scalp condition. It is priced at $15.0 and is among the top-30% of shampoos in terms of price. With 251 reviews and an overall rating of 3.8, it ranks in the top-30% of shampoos based on user feedback.

Pros

  • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (8 mentions, 88% positive): This shampoo is in the top-5% for treating flaky scalps, indicating high efficacy.
  • Effectiveness on oily hair (8 mentions, 92% positive): It also ranks in the top-5% for managing oily hair, showing excellent performance.
  • Effect on shiny hair (14 mentions, 100% positive): Users report that it significantly enhances hair shine, placing it in the top-30%.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (35 mentions, 86% positive): It is recognized for its cleaning ability, ranking in the top-40%.
  • Improvement of hair health (33 mentions, 91% positive): The shampoo is in the top-30% for improving hair health according to users.
  • Impact on scalp health (153 mentions, 74% positive): With a high number of mentions, it is in the top-10% for scalp health impact.
  • Shampoo chemical content (23 mentions, 78% positive): It is considered to have a favorable chemical composition, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Moisturizing effect (4 mentions, 100% positive): Users find it highly moisturizing, ranking it in the top-30%.

Average

  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (23 mentions, 96% positive): This attribute is well-regarded, placing the shampoo in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (10 mentions, 75% positive): It shows a good level of effectiveness on this condition, ranking in the top-20%.
  • Effectiveness on dandruff (48 mentions, 78% positive): The shampoo is in the top-20% for dandruff control.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (43 mentions, 68% positive): It moderately reduces hair dryness, placing it in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on damaged hair (5 mentions, 80% positive): It is considered effective for damaged hair, ranking in the top-30%.
  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (13 mentions, 62% positive): The shampoo has an average performance in removing residue, placing it in the top-50%.

Cons

  • Effectiveness on frizz control (5 mentions, 40% positive): It is less effective for frizz control, ranking in the bottom-20%.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (14 mentions, 70% positive): While it has some positive feedback, it is in the top-50%, indicating room for improvement.
  • Effectiveness in hair color preservation (2 mentions, 75% positive): There is limited feedback, but it suggests it may not be the best for color preservation, placing it in the bottom-20%.
  • Effectiveness on fungal infections (3 mentions, 100% positive): Despite limited mentions, it has a high positive response for treating fungal infections, ranking in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on hair growth (6 mentions, 100% positive): It receives high praise for promoting hair growth, placing it in the top-40%.
Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women photo

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Impact on scalp health” $12 at Amazon

BrandMaple Holistics
Amazon rating4.4
BeautyGooru rating4.6
Number of reviews4,988
Share of positive87%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”3.7
Number of mentions205
Share of positive mentions66%

Tea Tree Shampoo for Men and Women by Maple Holistics stands out as a high-performing product among the top shampoos available on Amazon, with a price of $12.00. It is among the top-20% in terms of price and has garnered a significant number of reviews, placing it in the top-5% with an overall rating of 4.6, which is also in the top-5% of shampoos.

Pros

  • Effectiveness on dandruff (1949 mentions, 98% positive): This shampoo is highly effective against dandruff, ranking in the top-5% of shampoos for this attribute.
  • Natural Ingredients (674 mentions, 96% positive): The use of natural ingredients is well-received, placing it in the top-5% of shampoos for this quality.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (817 mentions, 98% positive): It excels in cleaning hair, with a top-5% ranking based on user feedback.
  • Impact on scalp health (3013 mentions, 87% positive): The shampoo has a positive impact on scalp health, making it a top-5% choice for consumers.
  • Scent (1720 mentions, 95% positive): Users are highly satisfied with the scent, earning it a place in the top-5% of shampoos.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (1618 mentions, 82% positive): It is effective in reducing hair dryness post-shampooing, ranking in the top-10%.
  • Effect on hair manageability (114 mentions, 97% positive): This shampoo improves hair manageability, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Shampoo chemical content (486 mentions, 74% positive): The chemical content is considered positive by users, ranking in the top-20%.
  • Improvement of hair health (549 mentions, 100% positive): It is highly effective in improving hair health, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Effect on shiny hair (248 mentions, 97% positive): The shampoo contributes to shinier hair, ranking it in the top-40%.

Average

  • Effectiveness on oily hair (177 mentions, 76% positive): It has an average effectiveness on oily hair, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Curly or Wavy hair users shampoo experiences (66 mentions, 90% positive): Users with curly or wavy hair have had positive experiences, ranking it in the top-20%.
  • Moisturizing effect (191 mentions, 80% positive): The moisturizing effect is average, placing it in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (87 mentions, 80% positive): It has an average effectiveness on frizz control, ranking in the top-30%.
  • Sulfate-free shampoo (110 mentions, 79% positive): The sulfate-free aspect is considered average, placing it in the top-40%.

Cons

  • Effect on hair tangling (36 mentions, 56% positive): There are some concerns about its effect on hair tangling, placing it in the top-60%.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (158 mentions, 55% positive): The effectiveness on hair loss is a concern, ranking it in the top-60%.
  • Effectiveness on thinning hair (111 mentions, 81% positive): It has a moderate effectiveness on thinning hair, placing it in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on fungal infections (57 mentions, 72% positive): The shampoo’s effectiveness on fungal infections is considered average, ranking in the top-40%.
  • Effectiveness on psoriasis (121 mentions, 78% positive): It has a moderate effectiveness on psoriasis, placing it in the top-40%.
JVN Pre-Wash Scalp Oil & Hair Treatment Oil photo

JVN Pre-Wash Scalp Oil & Hair Treatment Oil

JVN Pre-Wash Scalp Oil & Hair Treatment Oil is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” $29 at Amazon

BrandJVN
Amazon rating4.4
BeautyGooru rating3.5
Number of reviews114
Share of positive80%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”4.5
Number of mentions9
Share of positive mentions83%

The JVN Pre-Wash Scalp Oil & Hair Treatment Oil stands out for its effectiveness in reducing hair dryness, improving flaky scalp conditions, and enhancing hair manageability, shine, and overall health. However, it shows average performance in moisturizing, softness, and damage repair, and falls short in removing residue and providing volume.

Pros

    • Hair Dryness Reduction (52 mentions, 79% positive): This shampoo is highly praised for significantly reducing hair dryness, ranking it among the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Flaky Scalp Effectiveness (9 mentions, 83% positive): It is exceptionally effective in addressing flaky scalp issues, placing it in the top 5% of shampoos.
    • Hair Manageability (4 mentions, 100% positive): Users report a notable improvement in hair manageability, categorizing it within the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Shiny Hair (16 mentions, 100% positive): The product ensures hair appears shinier, earning it a spot in the top 30% of shampoos.
    • Hair Health Improvement (29 mentions, 97% positive): It is highly effective in enhancing hair health, ranking it in the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Frizz Control (4 mentions, 100% positive): The shampoo excels in controlling frizz, placing it among the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Scalp Health Impact (76 mentions, 79% positive): It has a significant positive impact on scalp health, positioning it in the top 10% of shampoos.
    • Cleaning Effectiveness (5 mentions, 100% positive): Users find it highly effective in cleaning hair, ranking it in the top 50% of shampoos.

Average

    • Moisturizing Effect (13 mentions, 85% positive): The shampoo has a decent moisturizing effect, placing it in the top 40% of shampoos.
    • Softness/Silkiness (23 mentions, 96% positive): It generally improves hair softness or silkiness, ranking it in the top 40% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Damaged Hair (9 mentions, 72% positive): The shampoo shows moderate effectiveness on damaged hair, placing it in the top 40% of shampoos.
    • Shampoo Chemical Content (3 mentions, 100% positive): The chemical content is well-received, with it being in the top 50% of shampoos.
    • Scent (23 mentions, 74% positive): The scent is considered average, falling into the bottom 40% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Oily Hair (15 mentions, 52% positive): It has a moderate effect on oily hair, ranking it in the top 30% of shampoos.

Cons

    • Effectiveness on Thinning Hair (8 mentions, 63% positive): The shampoo is somewhat effective on thinning hair, placing it in the top 30% of shampoos.
    • Natural Ingredients (3 mentions, 67% positive): The use of natural ingredients is not a strong point, ranking it in the bottom 30% of shampoos.
    • Residue/Buildup Removal (6 mentions, 46% positive): It is less effective in removing residue or buildup, placing it in the bottom 10% of shampoos.
    • Fuller/Voluminous Hair (2 mentions, 100% positive): Despite positive feedback, it ranks in the bottom 10% for providing fuller and more voluminous hair.
    • Degreasing Properties (2 mentions, 50% positive): The shampoo’s degreasing properties are below average, falling into the bottom 40% of shampoos.
    • Hair Strengthening (3 mentions, 100% positive): Although positively reviewed, it ranks in the bottom 20% for hair strengthening.
Neutrogena T/Sal Therapeutic Shampoo photo

Neutrogena T/Sal Therapeutic Shampoo

Neutrogena T/Sal Therapeutic Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Impact on scalp health” $7.3 at Amazon

BrandNeutrogena
Amazon rating4.6
BeautyGooru rating4.1
Number of reviews410
Share of positive78%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”3.7
Number of mentions11
Share of positive mentions73%

Neutrogena T/Sal Therapeutic Shampoo stands out for its effectiveness in treating scalp conditions and improving scalp health, with high positive feedback in several key areas, making it a top choice for those with specific hair and scalp needs.

Pros

  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (52 mentions, 88% positive): This shampoo is highly praised for its ability to clear residue and buildup, ranking it among the top 5% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (24 mentions, 92% positive): Users with seborrheic dermatitis have found significant relief, placing it in the top 5% for this benefit.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (46 mentions, 87% positive): It is recognized for its thorough cleaning capabilities, positioning it in the top 20% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on damaged hair (7 mentions, 100% positive): Although mentioned less frequently, it has a perfect positive rating for treating damaged hair, ranking in the top 10%.
  • Effectiveness on psoriasis (38 mentions, 79% positive): It is highly effective against psoriasis, with a high positive response that places it in the top 5%.
  • Impact on scalp health (189 mentions, 85% positive): The shampoo has a strong reputation for improving scalp health, making it a top 5% choice.
  • Improvement of hair health (26 mentions, 96% positive): Users report significant improvements in hair health, ranking it in the top 20%.
  • Effect on shiny hair (9 mentions, 89% positive): It has a good track record for enhancing hair shine, placing it in the top 50%.

Average

  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (21 mentions, 90% positive): This shampoo has a favorable impact on hair softness, ranking it in the top 50%.
  • Effectiveness on dandruff (98 mentions, 75% positive): It shows a solid performance in combating dandruff, placing it in the top 20%.
  • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (11 mentions, 73% positive): It is relatively effective against a flaky scalp, ranking in the top 20%.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (61 mentions, 55% positive): The shampoo has a moderate success rate in reducing hair dryness, placing it in the top 60%.
  • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (5 mentions, 70% positive): It demonstrates average effectiveness in controlling frizz, ranking in the top 50%.
  • Effect on hair manageability (2 mentions, 100% positive): Although not widely mentioned, it has a perfect score for improving hair manageability, placing it in the top 50%.

Cons

  • Sulfate-free shampoo (2 mentions, 50% positive): It is not highly regarded for being sulfate-free, ranking in the bottom 20%.
  • Moisturizing effect (9 mentions, 56% positive): The shampoo lacks in providing moisture, with a low ranking in the bottom 20%.
  • Effectiveness on oily hair (7 mentions, 56% positive): It shows below-average results for oily hair management, placing it in the bottom 30%.
  • Effectiveness on hair loss (9 mentions, 39% positive): It has a lower positive response for treating hair loss, ranking in the top 60%.
  • Curly or Wavy hair users shampoo experiences (3 mentions, 17% positive): Users with curly or wavy hair report poor experiences, ranking it in the bottom 10%.
  • Effect on hair tangling (3 mentions, 33% positive): It is not particularly effective in preventing hair tangling, placing it in the bottom 20%.
Sage and Rosemary Sulfate Free Shampoo photo

Sage and Rosemary Sulfate Free Shampoo

Sage and Rosemary Sulfate Free Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” $24 at Amazon

BrandMaple Holistics
Amazon rating4.4
BeautyGooru rating4.3
Number of reviews4,993
Share of positive71%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”4
Number of mentions239
Share of positive mentions64%

The Sage and Rosemary Sulfate Free Shampoo by Maple Holistics is a high-performing product with a price in the top-50% of shampoos. It stands out for its natural ingredients and effectiveness in various aspects of hair care, as evidenced by its large number of reviews and high overall rating, placing it among the top shampoos available on Amazon.

Pros

  • Natural Ingredients (1105 mentions, 85% positive): This shampoo is highly regarded for its use of natural ingredients, ranking it in the top-5% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness in Cleaning Hair (811 mentions, 92% positive): Users find it very effective in cleaning hair, placing it in the top-20% of shampoos.
  • Effect on Shiny Hair (304 mentions, 97% positive): It is praised for enhancing hair’s shine, also ranking in the top-20%.
  • Effect on Hair Manageability (116 mentions, 99% positive): The shampoo scores high on improving hair manageability, within the top-20%.
  • Improvement of Hair Health (574 mentions, 100% positive): It is considered highly effective in improving hair health, placing it in the top-20%.
  • Effectiveness on Damaged Hair (270 mentions, 78% positive): This shampoo is well-received for its effectiveness on damaged hair, ranking in the top-20%.
  • Effectiveness on Flaky Scalp (239 mentions, 64% positive): It is among the top-10% of shampoos for its positive impact on flaky scalps.

Average

  • Sulfate-free Shampoo (272 mentions, 81% positive): It is considered a good sulfate-free option, placing it in the top-30% of shampoos.
  • Impact on Scalp Health (2528 mentions, 65% positive): The shampoo has a positive impact on scalp health, ranking in the top-20%.
  • Effect on Hair Softness or Silkiness (472 mentions, 93% positive): It is recognized for its effect on hair softness, placing it in the top-50%.
  • Effectiveness on Dandruff (2952 mentions, 64% positive): The shampoo is effective against dandruff, ranking in the top-20%.
  • Shampoo Chemical Content (944 mentions, 72% positive): Users are satisfied with its chemical content, placing it in the top-30%.
  • Effectiveness in Hair Strengthening (56 mentions, 93% positive): It is considered effective in strengthening hair, ranking in the top-50%.

Cons

  • Effectiveness on Oily Hair (173 mentions, 73% positive): The shampoo has mixed reviews for oily hair, placing it in the top-50%.
  • Effect on Hair Tangling (37 mentions, 64% positive): Some users find it less effective in preventing hair tangling, ranking it in the top-40%.
  • Curly or Wavy Hair Users Shampoo Experiences (73 mentions, 64% positive): It has lower satisfaction rates among users with curly or wavy hair, placing it in the bottom-30% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on Seborrheic Dermatitis (94 mentions, 69% positive): The shampoo shows moderate effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis, ranking in the top-30%.
  • Effectiveness in Hair Color Preservation (212 mentions, 83% positive): It is somewhat effective in preserving hair color, placing it in the top-60%.
  • Effectiveness on Hair Loss (265 mentions, 58% positive): The shampoo has moderate effectiveness on hair loss, ranking in the top-50%.
Davines Naturaltech PURIFYING Shampoo photo

Davines Naturaltech PURIFYING Shampoo

Davines Naturaltech PURIFYING Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”


$36 at Amazon

BrandDavines
Amazon rating4.6
BeautyGooru rating3.7
Number of reviews221
Share of positive76%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”4.5
Number of mentions10
Share of positive mentions85%

Davines Naturaltech PURIFYING Shampoo stands out for its effectiveness against dandruff and flaky scalp, with a high positive response in these areas. It also has a notable impact on scalp health. However, it has mixed reviews regarding its scent and effectiveness in certain areas such as residue removal and hair health improvement.

Pros

  • Effectiveness on dandruff (103 mentions, 86% positive): This shampoo is highly praised for its ability to combat dandruff, ranking it among the top 5% of shampoos.
  • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (10 mentions, 85% positive): Users have reported significant improvement in flaky scalp conditions, placing it in the top 5% for this benefit.
  • Impact on scalp health (86 mentions, 81% positive): The shampoo is recognized for its positive effects on overall scalp health, earning it a spot in the top 10% of shampoos.

Average

  • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (7 mentions, 100% positive): While not a standout feature, the shampoo does contribute to hair softness or silkiness, ranking in the top 60%.
  • Effectiveness on oily hair (7 mentions, 75% positive): It shows a decent performance in managing oily hair, placing it in the top 20%.
  • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (46 mentions, 64% positive): The shampoo has a moderate success rate in reducing hair dryness, positioning it in the top 40%.
  • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (7 mentions, 71% positive): It is fairly effective against seborrheic dermatitis, ranking in the top 30%.
  • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (20 mentions, 80% positive): The shampoo’s cleaning efficacy is average, falling into the bottom 40%.
  • Effectiveness on damaged hair (2 mentions, 100% positive): It has a positive effect on damaged hair, although not a leading feature, placing it in the top 60%.
  • Natural ingredients (9 mentions, 67% positive): The use of natural ingredients is considered average, with the shampoo in the bottom 40% in this regard.
  • Effect on shiny hair (3 mentions, 100% positive): While it does contribute to shiny hair, it’s not a prominent attribute, ranking in the bottom 40%.
  • Curly or wavy hair users shampoo experiences (3 mentions, 100% positive): The shampoo is fairly well-received by those with curly or wavy hair, placing it in the top 60%.

Cons

  • Effect on hair manageability (3 mentions, 67% positive): Some users find the shampoo lacking in improving hair manageability, putting it in the bottom 20%.
  • Effectiveness on psoriasis (7 mentions, 64% positive): While somewhat effective for psoriasis, it ranks in the top 30%, indicating room for improvement.
  • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (8 mentions, 58% positive): The shampoo struggles with removing residue or buildup, placing it in the bottom 20%.
  • Effectiveness on frizz control (3 mentions, 67% positive): It has a below-average performance in controlling frizz, ranking in the bottom 30%.
  • Improvement of hair health (11 mentions, 73% positive): Users report that it does not significantly improve hair health, positioning it in the bottom 20%.
  • Scent (54 mentions, 51% positive): The scent of the shampoo is not well-received, with it being in the bottom 20% for this attribute.
  • Effectiveness in hair color preservation (8 mentions, 67% positive): It is less effective in preserving hair color, ranking in the bottom 30%.
Trader Joe's Tea Tree Tingle Shampoo photo

Trader Joe’s Tea Tree Tingle Shampoo

Trader Joe’s Tea Tree Tingle Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best budget
Best shampoo in “Impact on scalp health”


$13.5 at Amazon

BrandTrader Joe’s
Amazon rating4.5
BeautyGooru rating4.1
Number of reviews525
Share of positive72%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”3.9
Number of mentions7
Share of positive mentions93%

Trader Joe’s Tea Tree Tingle Shampoo stands out among the top shampoos on Amazon for its effectiveness in cleaning hair, pleasant scent, natural ingredients, and positive impact on scalp health. It is priced at $13.5 and has garnered 525 reviews with an overall rating of 4.1, placing it among the top-rated shampoos.

Pros

    • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (129 mentions, 94% positive): This shampoo ranks in the top 5% for its ability to clean hair thoroughly, according to user reviews.
    • Scent (184 mentions, 95% positive): The fragrance of this shampoo is highly appreciated, placing it in the top 5% for scent.
    • Natural Ingredients (64 mentions, 86% positive): Users value the natural ingredients in this shampoo, earning it a spot in the top 5% in this category.
    • Impact on scalp health (139 mentions, 88% positive): The shampoo’s beneficial effects on scalp health place it in the top 5% of shampoos.
    • Shampoo chemical content (53 mentions, 81% positive): The chemical composition of this shampoo is well-regarded, ranking it in the top 20%.
    • Effect on shiny hair (17 mentions, 88% positive): It performs moderately well in enhancing hair shine, placing it in the top 50%.
    • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (65 mentions, 73% positive): This shampoo is considered effective in removing residue or buildup, ranking in the top 30%.

Average

    • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (7 mentions, 93% positive): It has a good reputation for addressing flaky scalp issues, placing it in the top 20%.
    • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (83 mentions, 58% positive): This shampoo has mixed reviews regarding its ability to reduce hair dryness, ranking in the top 60%.
    • Curly or Wavy hair users shampoo experiences (22 mentions, 84% positive): It is fairly well-received by those with curly or wavy hair, placing it in the top 40%.
    • Effect on hair manageability (4 mentions, 63% positive): The shampoo has average performance in improving hair manageability, ranking in the top 60%.
    • Effectiveness on oily hair (20 mentions, 60% positive): It is moderately effective for oily hair, placing it in the top 30%.
    • Sulfate-free shampoo (22 mentions, 58% positive): The shampoo’s sulfate-free formula receives average feedback, ranking it in the top 50%.
    • Effectiveness on dandruff (49 mentions, 82% positive): It is considered quite effective against dandruff, placing it in the top 20%.

Cons

    • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (26 mentions, 81% positive): This shampoo is less effective in improving hair softness or silkiness, placing it in the bottom 20%.
    • Improvement of hair health (28 mentions, 68% positive): It has lower ratings for overall hair health improvement, ranking in the bottom 20%.
    • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (13 mentions, 44% positive): Users report it is less effective for frizz control, placing it in the bottom 20%.
    • Effect on hair tangling (6 mentions, 50% positive): The shampoo has mixed reviews on reducing hair tangling, ranking in the bottom 40%.
    • Effectiveness on hair loss (4 mentions, 50% positive): It has average effectiveness in addressing hair loss, placing it in the top 60%.
    • Effectiveness in hair color preservation (10 mentions, 55% positive): It is less effective in preserving hair color, ranking in the bottom 20%.
Ethique Heali Kiwi Calming Solid Shampoo Bar photo

Ethique Heali Kiwi Calming Solid Shampoo Bar

Ethique Heali Kiwi Calming Solid Shampoo Bar is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”


$15.5 at Amazon

BrandEthique
Amazon rating4.5
BeautyGooru rating4.4
Number of reviews875
Share of positive75%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”4
Number of mentions42
Share of positive mentions67%

The Ethique Heali Kiwi Calming Solid Shampoo Bar is a highly regarded shampoo among users on Amazon, particularly praised for its effectiveness in cleaning and improving hair health, as well as its positive impact on oily hair and flaky scalp. It stands out in the top percentages for several attributes, indicating a strong performance in key areas.

Pros

    • Cleaning Effectiveness (200 mentions, 87% positive): This shampoo ranks in the top 10% for its ability to clean hair thoroughly, leaving it free from dirt and grime.
    • Hair Health Improvement (123 mentions, 92% positive): It is in the top 20% for enhancing hair health, suggesting that it contributes to stronger and healthier hair.
    • Shiny Hair Effect (78 mentions, 93% positive): Users rate it in the top 20% for adding shine to hair, indicating a noticeable gloss after use.
    • Residue Removal (110 mentions, 78% positive): It stands in the top 20% for its ability to remove buildup, making it suitable for those concerned with product residue.
    • Oily Hair Effectiveness (57 mentions, 75% positive): This shampoo is among the top 10% for managing oily hair, helping to balance scalp oils.
    • Dryness Reduction (218 mentions, 69% positive): It is in the top 30% for reducing hair dryness, suggesting it is a good option for those with dry hair concerns.
    • Softness/Silkiness Effect (125 mentions, 89% positive): The shampoo ranks in the top 30% for making hair feel soft and silky to the touch.
    • Flaky Scalp Effectiveness (42 mentions, 67% positive): It is in the top 10% for addressing flaky scalp issues, which may be beneficial for those with dandruff.
    • Degreasing Properties (11 mentions, 91% positive): Users find it to be in the top 20% for degreasing hair, which can be particularly useful for those with excessively oily scalps.

Average

    • Scalp Health Impact (355 mentions, 70% positive): The shampoo is in the top 20% for promoting a healthy scalp, which is a fundamental aspect of hair care.
    • Natural Ingredients (56 mentions, 75% positive): It ranks in the top 40% for containing natural ingredients, appealing to those looking for a more organic hair care option.
    • Dandruff Effectiveness (284 mentions, 64% positive): This shampoo is in the top 20% for combating dandruff, making it a viable choice for those dealing with this issue.
    • Scent (266 mentions, 81% positive): It is in the top 40% for having a pleasant fragrance, which enhances the overall user experience.
    • Moisturizing Effect (38 mentions, 82% positive): The shampoo ranks in the top 40% for its moisturizing properties, which can help prevent dryness.
    • Chemical Content (48 mentions, 71% positive): It is in the top 30% for having a favorable chemical composition, which is important for those concerned about harsh ingredients.

Cons

    • Hair Tangling Effect (10 mentions, 60% positive): The shampoo is in the top 50% for its impact on hair tangling, indicating that some users may experience issues with tangles after use.
    • Hair Loss Effectiveness (21 mentions, 56% positive): It ranks in the top 60% for addressing hair loss, suggesting that it may not be the most effective option for this concern.
    • Thinning Hair Effectiveness (13 mentions, 77% positive): The shampoo is in the top 40% for helping with thinning hair, which could be beneficial for those noticing a decrease in hair density.
    • Psoriasis Effectiveness (12 mentions, 96% positive): It ranks in the top 40% for its positive effects on psoriasis, indicating that it may help alleviate symptoms for some users.
    • Seborrheic Dermatitis Effectiveness (6 mentions, 67% positive): The shampoo is in the top 40% for treating seborrheic dermatitis, which could be helpful for those with this scalp condition.
Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo photo

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best brand with focus on “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”


$16.9 at Amazon

BrandNeutrogena
Amazon rating4.6
BeautyGooru rating4.4
Number of reviews2,526
Share of positive62%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”4
Number of mentions86
Share of positive mentions79%

Neutrogena T/Gel Therapeutic Shampoo stands out for its effectiveness in treating scalp conditions such as psoriasis, dandruff, and flaky scalp, with high positive feedback from users. However, it falls short in areas like scent and hair strengthening, with a notable number of negative reviews.

Pros

    • Effectiveness on psoriasis (195 mentions, 87% positive): This shampoo is highly praised for its ability to alleviate psoriasis symptoms, ranking it among the top shampoos for this condition.
    • Effectiveness on dandruff (772 mentions, 81% positive): A significant number of users have found it effective in reducing dandruff, placing it in the top tier for dandruff treatment.
    • Effectiveness in cleaning hair (106 mentions, 90% positive): It is recognized for its strong cleaning capabilities, making it a reliable choice for hair hygiene.
    • Effectiveness on flaky scalp (86 mentions, 79% positive): Users report that it effectively combats flaky scalp issues, securing its position as a top choice for this concern.

Average

    • Impact on scalp health (898 mentions, 72% positive): The shampoo has a generally positive impact on overall scalp health, with a majority of users noting improvements.
    • Effectiveness on seborrheic dermatitis (74 mentions, 82% positive): It shows good results for those dealing with seborrheic dermatitis, with a high percentage of positive experiences.
    • Effect on hair softness or silkiness (46 mentions, 89% positive): Some users find that it contributes to softer or silkier hair, although this is not its primary benefit.
    • Effectiveness in residue or buildup removal (45 mentions, 63% positive): It is moderately effective at removing residue or buildup from the hair.
    • Effectiveness on damaged hair (48 mentions, 71% positive): The shampoo has a fair success rate in treating damaged hair according to user feedback.
    • Moisturizing effect (8 mentions, 75% positive): A small number of users mention a moisturizing effect, but it is not a standout feature.
    • Effect on hair manageability (11 mentions, 64% positive): It has an average impact on making hair more manageable.
    • Hair dryness reduction after shampooing (308 mentions, 51% positive): Opinions are split on its ability to reduce hair dryness, with about half of the users noticing an improvement.

Cons

    • Effectiveness on oily hair (40 mentions, 59% positive): The shampoo has mixed results when it comes to treating oily hair, with a slight majority finding it effective.
    • Scent (925 mentions, 38% positive): The scent is a significant downside, with a large number of users disliking it.
    • Effectiveness in hair strengthening (13 mentions, 85% positive): Despite a high percentage of positive mentions, the low number of mentions suggests it is not a notable benefit.
    • Effectiveness on frizz control (14 mentions, 52% positive): It has a below-average performance in controlling frizz according to user reviews.
    • Natural ingredients (33 mentions, 55% positive): There is some concern about the naturalness of the ingredients, with a moderate level of satisfaction.
    • Effectiveness in hair color preservation (14 mentions, 62% positive): It does not excel in preserving hair color, with a relatively low number of positive mentions.
    • Effectiveness on hair loss (49 mentions, 43% positive): The shampoo is not highly regarded for treating hair loss, with more users reporting dissatisfaction.
    • Squeaky clean hair feeling after shampoo use (3 mentions, 67% positive): There are very few mentions of the shampoo leaving a squeaky clean feeling, indicating it is not a significant feature.
Puriya Sulfate Free Tea Tree Shampoo photo

Puriya Sulfate Free Tea Tree Shampoo

Puriya Sulfate Free Tea Tree Shampoo is in top-10 in the following nominations: Best shampoo in combination of “Effectiveness on flaky scalp” and other attributes
Best shampoo in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”


$25.1 at Amazon

BrandPuriya
Amazon rating4.2
BeautyGooru rating4.2
Number of reviews1,226
Share of positive75%
BeautyGooru rating in “Effectiveness on flaky scalp”4
Number of mentions77
Share of positive mentions69%

Puriya Sulfate Free Tea Tree Shampoo stands out for its natural ingredients and effectiveness in improving hair health, cleaning, and controlling frizz. It is well-regarded for its sulfate-free formula and positive impact on scalp health, though it shows less effectiveness in managing oily hair and degreasing.

Pros

    • Natural Ingredients (101 mentions, 88% positive): Highly praised for its natural formulation, ranking in the top 5% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness in Cleaning Hair (138 mentions, 90% positive): Recognized for its cleaning power, placing it in the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Frizz Control (20 mentions, 90% positive): Valued for controlling frizz, ranking in the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Shampoo Chemical Content (102 mentions, 82% positive): Appreciated for its chemical composition, placing it in the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Improvement of Hair Health (104 mentions, 95% positive): Noted for significantly enhancing hair health, ranking in the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Effect on Shiny Hair (52 mentions, 96% positive): Commended for boosting hair’s shine, placing it in the top 40% of shampoos.
    • Moisturizing Effect (55 mentions, 85% positive): Acknowledged for its moisturizing properties, ranking in the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Hair Dryness Reduction after Shampooing (324 mentions, 66% positive): Recognized for reducing hair dryness, placing it in the top 30% of shampoos.
    • Effect on Hair Softness or Silkiness (134 mentions, 89% positive): Valued for making hair softer or silkier, ranking in the top 30% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Flaky Scalp (77 mentions, 69% positive): Effective against flaky scalp, placing it in the top 10% of shampoos.

Average

    • Impact on Scalp Health (741 mentions, 71% positive): Has a positive impact on scalp health, ranking in the top 20% of shampoos.
    • Effect on Hair Tangling (12 mentions, 92% positive): Helps to reduce hair tangling, placing it in the top 10% of shampoos.
    • Effect on Hair Manageability (30 mentions, 82% positive): Improves hair manageability, ranking in the top 30% of shampoos.
    • Sulfate-free Shampoo (36 mentions, 83% positive): Its sulfate-free nature is well-received, placing it in the top 30% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Dandruff (378 mentions, 71% positive): Shows effectiveness against dandruff, ranking in the top 20% of shampoos.

Cons

    • Effectiveness on Oily Hair (30 mentions, 48% positive): Less effective on oily hair, placing it in the bottom 30% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Hair Loss (26 mentions, 56% positive): Shows moderate effectiveness on hair loss, ranking in the top 60% of shampoos.
    • Degreasing Properties (6 mentions, 50% positive): Not highly effective in degreasing, placing it in the bottom 20% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Thinning Hair (23 mentions, 54% positive): Moderately effective on thinning hair, ranking in the top 40% of shampoos.
    • Effectiveness on Fungal Infections (7 mentions, 57% positive): Somewhat effective against fungal infections, placing it in the top 40% of shampoos.

How We Rank

We strongly believe that reviews of actual customers who used shampoo is the best source of information on actual performance of a shampoo and in particular of detailed performance aspects like effectiveness for different hair types, various health, visual and tactile effects and also side effects. To make our analysis and scoring we apply the following methodology:

  • We use AI to analyze reviews in shampoo category and identify major topics on which customers focus their attention when reviewing a shampoo such as performance for different types of hair, scent, effectiveness against scalp and hair problems such as dryness, flakiness or oiliness and such other effects like moisturizing, shine, effect on hair tangling etc.
  • After identification of major topics within shampoo category which we name product attributes we use proprietary AI algorithms to find all mentions on every traced attribute for every shampoo which we take into research.
  • For every shampoo and attribute we calculate many metrics like total number of mentions on attribute, its share in total reviews, share of positive and negative sentiments etc. We then compare these metrics for different shampoos and elaborate comparative score of every shampoo against its peers and make it separately for every attribute.

Why Trust BeautyGooru?

Deborah Jones, the mastermind behind BeautyGooru, employs an AI-driven method to analyze thousands of Amazon reviews, guaranteeing precise and trustworthy recommendations. With her vast experience spanning product development to brand consultancy, Deborah possesses a rare ability to discern shampoo efficacy and ingredient effectiveness. Beyond ratings, she taps into real consumer feedback, providing insights that resonate with the needs and desires of online shoppers.

8 Comments
  1. Do these shampoos only soothe the itch or do they also treat the underlying cause?

    • The shampoos listed are formulated to both soothe itchiness and address its underlying causes, such as dryness or scalp conditions, providing a more comprehensive solution to the problem.

  2. I have sensitive skin and certain shampoos trigger my scalp itchiness. Are the products on this list suitable for sensitive skin?

    • The shampoos on this list for dry hair are selected with a focus on gentle and hydrating formulas, making many of them suitable for sensitive skin. However, it’s important to check individual product ingredients for any known irritants or allergens specific to your skin sensitivity. Look for shampoos labeled as hypoallergenic or formulated for sensitive skin to reduce the risk of triggering scalp itchiness.

  3. I’ve had an itchy scalp for as long as I can remember. Would these shampoos provide immediate relief?

    • Many of the shampoos designed for an itchy scalp aim to provide immediate relief by soothing the scalp and targeting the causes of itchiness. While immediate effects can vary from person to person, these formulations are generally made to offer quick comfort and start addressing the underlying issues from the first use.

  4. I’m wary of chemicals and prefer natural ingredients. Are there any natural options on this list?

    • Our list includes options with natural ingredients catering to those who prefer to avoid harsh chemicals. Look for shampoos featuring organic or naturally derived components, which are gentle on the hair and scalp while effectively treating dryness. These natural options can provide the nourishment and hydration your dry hair needs without relying on synthetic chemicals.

    Leave a reply

    BEAUTYGOORU
    Logo
    Compare items
    • Total (0)
    Compare
    0